When people ask me what my favorite restaurant is in Cleveland, my answer is always the same—Tommy’s on Coventry. It’s not just a place to eat. It’s a place that feels like Cleveland: diverse, welcoming, unpretentious, and quietly legendary. Tucked into the quirky, artsy stretch of Coventry Road in Cleveland Heights, Tommy’s has long been my go-to for comfort food, great memories, and the kind of vibe that only a truly beloved local spot can serve up.
Let me take you there for a minute.
A Spot Steeped in Soul
Tommy’s isn’t fancy. It doesn’t try to be. The wood booths are worn in just right. The walls are decorated with local art and photos from decades past. It’s the kind of place where you can come as you are—whether you’re a tattooed musician, a vegan poet, a college kid craving fries, or a family out on a casual night. Everyone fits at Tommy’s. That’s part of the magic.
It’s been around since 1972, and it shows in the best way. Generations have come through here. And while other trendy spots pop up and fade, Tommy’s just keeps doing its thing—and doing it well.
The Food: Legendary and Loaded with Personality
Let’s talk about the menu. It’s a beast, and I mean that in the best way. You could walk in craving literally anything and Tommy’s has your back.
Craving something hearty? Go for the Dani—a grilled cheese sandwich layered with falafel, veggies, and cheese. Feeling health-conscious? The Lara (a savory spinach pie with veggies and tofu) is one of the best vegetarian meals I’ve ever had. And if you’re feeling classic, a milkshake and fries combo here hits different.
The best part? They’re one of those rare places that caters to everyone. Carnivores, vegetarians, vegans, gluten-free diners—no one’s left out. That kind of inclusive menu isn’t just appreciated, it’s celebrated.
Tommy’s Vibes Are Immaculate
You know that moment when you walk into a place and instantly relax? That’s Tommy’s. There’s something about the energy here—calm, lived-in, happy—that makes it feel like more than just a restaurant. It feels like a third place, that vital community spot where people meet, talk, eat, and just be.
You’ll see first dates nervously laughing over milkshakes. You’ll see solo diners reading a book in peace. You’ll see families talking across big booths, sharing fries by the handful. I’ve had late lunches that turned into early dinners here, just because I didn’t want to leave.
Why It Matters to Me
Tommy’s has seen me through a lot. First college breaks. Weird dates. Long talks with friends. Quick pit stops on a snowy night. When I think of Cleveland, I think of this place.
It reminds me of what I love about this city—how it blends grit and warmth, flavor and friendliness, tradition and reinvention. Tommy’s is Cleveland, in restaurant form.
Final Thoughts
We all have those places that feel like ours. Not because we own them, but because they’ve owned a little piece of our heart for years. Tommy’s is that for me. And if you’ve never been, do yourself a favor. Go. Order something wild. Try the milkshake. Talk to the server. Soak up the vibe.
And who knows—maybe it’ll become your favorite spot, too.
Because in a world of constant change, it’s good to know that some things—like a perfectly crispy falafel wrap and a chocolate milkshake served with a smile—never go out of style.
What If I...? 